Cat on a Hot Tin Roof: Tennessee Williams's southern discomfort | Stage | The Guardian
ghosts; it is gently and poetically haunted by a relationship that must have involved a contrast to Brick's betrayal of Skipper's friendship, the Straw-Ochello . Paul Newman as Brick and Elizabeth Taylor as Maggie in Cat on a Hot Tin Roof He will ask him about Skipper and Brick will holler back: "You're . was Brick's homosexual relationship skipper and that knowledge just got. Since he and Skipper only have ever held hands, he believes them to have had only a platonic relationship. In Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, Brick.
However, their marriages are upheld by a false domination over their wives. The wives know there is something different about their husbands.
Brick, who only knows what society tells him to be homosexual, does not believe he is. To Brick, it is the physical sexual act which makes someone homosexual. Since he and Skipper only have ever held hands, he believes them to have had only a platonic relationship.
Brick is constantly bombarded with accusations and questions about his relationship with Skipper. Joe, on the other hand, admits to himself that his feelings are unconventional. Both Brick and Joe are in unhappy marriages but feel obligated to uphold appearances in order to fit into society.
However, it does not work.
Literary Interpretations and Homosexual Identity
Brick goes on a downward spiral into an alcoholic mess, and Joe tries to ignore his feelings completely. Therefore we see, as Powers suggests: It is interesting to note the similarities and differences in characters and their reactions to their situations.
When looking at Brick and Joe, there is a distinct difference in action in relation to their feelings. They are both in an existential conundrum of identity crises. While at the same time, the opposite happens to Joe. It is not that he is homosexual, but rather, that he will not admit it to her. Therefore, Harper was able to take on the role of a defiant housewife Bak At this time in history, many people could not comprehend that they could act against the grain of society or they were too afraid.
To some, Ronald Reagan was a wishy-washy president who rarely made his own decisions or issued orders. He was a hollow man White With his political stance and work as a Chief Clerk, he is discriminating and oppressing himself without even realizing it.
Homosexuality the Problem in Brick in Cat on a Hot Tin Roof
It is only when Louis calls him out on it that he takes a second look at what he has been doing with his life. When Joe finally engages in a sexual relationship with Louis, he begins to feel free for the first time in his life.
He becomes willing to accept his sexual identity and leave societal pressures behind. This is apparent in a conversation with Louis one morning: Your past, your beliefs, your… Kushner The fact Joe is willing to stop wearing his Mormon temple garment shows he is ready to take on a new identity. This emphasizes the effect of freedom to be oneself.
Joe finally can leave his inhibitions behind and not feel guilty. Unfortunately, this was not the case for Brick. While Joe acts on his feelings, Brick just stuffs his away. Brick lives in a small world of pain and alcohol and never comes to terms with his identity. The only identity he knew of himself was that of an athlete. She continuously tries to get Brick to have sex with her and he refuses. Maggie antagonizes Brick by prying about Skipper, which infuriates him.
Maggie tells Brick and Skipper a truth they do not want to admit, which leads to the death of Skipper. Brick blames Maggie and partly himself for the death of Skipper. Maggie clings to Brick for financial reasons but for love as well. Despite what has happened, Maggie loves Brick. Her love for him is also shown when she has sex with Skipper. Throughout the play, Maggie tries her best to put on a front for the family to prove to everyone that her and Brick are happily married.You Started Drinking With Your Friend Skipper's Death!
Brick has already lost all desire, and he only cares about alcohol. Harper is the opposite in many ways. Although both wives love their husbands, they deal with their ambiguous sexuality differently. It is important to note that I believe Joe to love Harper, just not romantically. He has a special sense of caring and love for her, but he cannot fulfill the husband role. In Angels in America, we see how Harper does not try to fix the family, like Maggie does.
For example, in Angels: I had a lot to think about. My dinner was fine.
I put it back in the oven and turned everything up as high as it could go and I watched till it burned black. It just seemed like the kind of thing a mentally deranged sex-starved pill-popping housewife would do. Kushner 42 Harper continues to confront Joe about his sexuality, much like Maggie does. However, Harper gets an admission from Joe and wants to leave him. Maggie thinks she knows Brick is homosexual, but she still wants to stay with him.
Interestingly, both Maggie and Harper use one thing to try and take control of their marriages—pregnancy. They both wish that a baby would reunite them and restore love and sexuality back into their marriages.
Both women suffer over the loss of love from their husbands. In Cat, Maggie exclaims: You know, if I thought you would never, never, never make love to me again—I would go downstairs to the kitchen and pick out the longest and sharpest knife I could find and stick it straight into my heart, I swear that I would! Williams In Angels, Harper reacts in a similar way: When your heart breaks, you should die.
When a person steps out of the role society gave them, they are looked at as abnormal.
Brick and Maggie’s Relationship (or lack thereof) | Love, Citizenship, and Belonging
For both couples, the struggle took its toll. The institution of marriage gives couples a false sense of how each partner is supposed to act. He married Maggie in a hurry just to prove that he was not the homosexual that people thought him to be: Maggie mentions that he was slow, indifferent and calm in his sexual intercourse, and though she says she like that sort of sex, we doubt that he was passive and indifferent because of the hangover of his homosexual relation and yearning for Skipper.
But, later when Skipper made a long distance call and openly proposed to Brick to leave his wife and join him, he did not talk any more on the phone. He hung up the phone. If he fully loved his wife and enjoyed sex with her, he would say no to Skipper, and if he hated it and also had the courage to face the society, he would say yes. But he could say neither. This means that Brick is a homosexual, but he wanted to play a double-role and be both a homo and heterosexual!
He can compromise neither with his social image, nor with his platonic ideal. He represents the homosexual personality of the era of its transition, and thus also its failure and crisis. The author has only been able to present the debate before us, and not advocate for or deny this new phenomenon of homosexuality. Brick is narcissistic to a great extent. The discussion of his dual orientation in sexuality can be taken to be caused by his self-centered behavior. He could neither love Skipper whole-heartedly, and nor could he love Maggie, who loves him so passionately, so truly and so faithfully.
The name of his wine "Echo Spring" is an indication that Brick is Narcissus.
- Homosexuality the Problem in Brick in Cat on a Hot Tin Roof
- The Cat on a Hit Tin Roof film may be censored – but in some ways it's superior
- Cat on a Hot Tin Roof: Tennessee Williams's southern discomfort
The mythical self-lover ran away from Echo Maggie and reached a spring well where he saw his own image and madly fell in love with it. Perhaps, Brick's finds his own image, in the experience of the 'click' caused by his alcohol.
To some extent, Brick is a schizoid; and his being a schizoid is also caused by his hostility towards a family and society that is hostile against the very idea of homosexuality. Such persons with schizotypal personality disorder engage in odd thinking and behavior.
They feel very uncomfortable with close personal relationships and tend to be suspicious of others. It doesn't seem that Brick is cured even at the end, even under the loads of social and psychological pressures.
Another problem related to and caused by his homosexuality is that of being psychologically and morally paralyzed. The consciousness of the social stigma attached to homosexuality breaks down Brick's mind and spirit.